Trump's immigration reversal creates its own chaos

Trump’s immigration reversal creates its own chaos

Originally published by CNN

President Donald Trump's biggest reversal is sparking fresh political and legal chaos -- and new accusations of inhumanity toward undocumented migrant children split from their parents at the southern border.

Trump on Wednesday bowed to relentless pressure in the US and around the world and signed an executive order that the White House said would keep families who cross into the US illegally together.
"You're going to have a lot of happy people," Trump said as he signed the order, billing it as the most significant presidential move on immigration in half a century -- even though he was fixing a problem his own administration had caused.

But as details of his damage control emerged, it became clear that it could cause a long list of fresh complications. And the White House's credibility was undermined because it had spent days insisting Wednesday's move was not possible and blaming Democrats for the mess.
Meanwhile, hopes that Congress could end the latest crisis at the southern border with votes Thursday on several substantial immigration bills were tempered by familiar schisms among lawmakers on perhaps the most divisive issue in modern politics.

The most glaring deficiency of the President's executive order was that it stunningly did nothing for more than 2,300 children already separated from their parents, some of whom have been held in cage-like conditions or have been sent to facilities around the country.
CNN's Tal Kopan, citing a senior government official, reported earlier Wednesday that the order did not contain any procedures for how to reunite children now in the care of the federal government with their parents. The agency later walked back the statement but said any further plans to reunite families were still in development.
"I think the intention was to change things (but) I think there is a lot of confusion. Frankly, I think the way the order is drafted is not executable," John Sandweg, a former director of US Immigration and Customs Enforcement, told CNN's Anderson Cooper.
"I was really shocked to see they are not going to unite the kids. I thought the whole point of this was to reunite the kids," he said.

That reality will impose extreme pressure on the administration to quickly find a fix to ensure that the politically damaging controversy does not get even worse.
The President mentioned the reversal only in passing at a campaign event in Minnesota on Wednesday night.
"Today, I signed an executive order," he said. "We're going to keep families together, but the border is going to be just as tough as it's been."
Immigration was the foundational issue of Trump's 2016 campaign and it forms the essential link between the President and his followers. So while his retreat is embarrassing, it's unlikely to signal any softening of his broader stance on undocumented immigrants.
Thursday morning he continued to express his displeasure with current immigration laws and mislead about the state of US immigration courts.
"We shouldn't be hiring judges by the thousands, as our ridiculous immigration laws demand, we should be changing our laws, building the Wall, hire Border Agents and Ice and not let people come into our country based on the legal phrase they are told to say as their password," Trump tweeted.
His own Justice Department is trying to hire a few dozen immigration judges, not thousands, and the move is widely seen across bipartisan lines as a way to expedite hearings and clear a backlog of cases.
While the President was campaigning Wednesday night, his critics accused him of solving the problem of separations by simply ordering the locking up of entire families indefinitely.
"When you have the most powerful nation on Earth saying that it is acceptable to detain families indefinitely, you are sending a signal to countries around the world that this is how they can treat immigrants and minorities," said Sen. Bernie Sanders, an independent from Vermont.
Unlikely odds for legislation passage
Congress could change the dynamic Thursday when the House votes on several bills that include language that would permanently end family separations.
But even if one of the measures passes, its inclusion of elements of Trump's hardline changes to legal immigration policy seems almost certain to kill it in the Senate.
Republican Rep. Markwayne Mullin of Oklahoma told reporters that Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen argued that the President's executive order had only bought time for Congress to change the law after a Capitol Hill briefing on Wednesday night.
"She essentially said, 'Look, the President is trying to give Congress a little wiggle room on this but we do need Congress to act,' " Mullin said.
While the political situation is murky, the legal challenges to the executive order may be even more complex.
Under the Trump administration's new policy adopted earlier this year, many people are funneled into the criminal justice system when they cross the border illegally -- and US guidelines mandate at that point that children are separated from their parents.
The executive order lays down new guidelines, requiring families to be kept together in the custody of the Department of Homeland Security.
But that position is almost certain to be challenged in court because of a 1997 consent agreement that stipulates that children can be kept in detention only for 20 days.
That decision could even lead to families being separated again.
"It's absolutely a possibility," Jonathan Turley, a George Washington University professor of law, said on CNN, laying out two possibilities if the administration could not get the consent agreement modified, a scenario he judged as doubtful.
"You reunite the family; a clock is ticking. If it goes beyond 20 days, you either release the entire family, which is similar to the Obama policy that the President wants to change," said Turley. "Or you once again separate the family and send the child into some type of custodial care."
CNN's Tal Kopan contributed to this report.


Related Articles

A Day in the Life of a Lawyer at the Border

Immigrant kids seen held in fenced cages at border facility

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.


%d bloggers like this: