Originally Published in The Washington Post
Teo Armus - January 6, 2021
When his comments quickly went viral, stoking outrage from critics, Nebraska officials rushed to clarify. Immigrants would still qualify for the vaccine, one Ricketts aide said, but those without legal status would have to wait at the back of the line.
“Nebraska is going to prioritize citizens and legal residents ahead of illegal immigrants,” the governor’s communications director, Taylor Gage, wrote on Twitter on Monday.
That approach still angered many advocates, who argue it could brew mistrust and scare immigrants away from an immunization campaign meant to reach as many people in Nebraska as possible. Despite the remarks from Ricketts, hundreds of undocumented workers do in fact work in the crowded, high-risk facilities deemed essential to the nation’s food supply, they say.
“This virus isn’t discriminating based on immigration status,” Dulce Castañeda, an organizer with the activist group Children of Smithfield, said in an interview with The Washington Post. “It doesn’t ask people if they’re a citizen, if they’re a resident, if they’re on a visa. So why would we ask that for vaccines?”
Most states, including Nebraska, have been abiding by federal recommendations to provide vaccines to front-line health-care workers first, followed by residents and staff at nursing homes. But the question of who should get the vaccine next, and when, has proved politically fraught across the nation.
Republican governors in Texas and Florida have bucked the advice of public health officials to focus on essential front-line workers, instead opting to rush vaccinations to a wider swath of the elderly. In Colorado, Gov. Jared Polis (D) redrafted a heavily criticized plan that put inmates, who have faced some of the nation’s deadliest outbreaks, before those with chronic health conditions.
Yet no other state appears have publicly suggested it will consider legal status in its immunization campaign — a move that even federal officials have warned could be dangerous.
“No one in this country should be denied a vaccine because of their documentation status, because it’s not ethically right to deny those individuals,” U.S. Surgeon General Jerome Adams told CBS’s “Face the Nation” last month.
James Goddard, the senior programs director at the nonprofit Nebraska Appleseed, said in an interview with The Post that it was “alarming” Ricketts could make undocumented immigrants wait longer for a vaccine. Many are essential workers who in fact deserve high priority given their risk of exposure, he said, and it would be logistically impossible — and potentially illegal — to screen their legal status while administering vaccines.
“It’s terrible public-health policy,” he said. “Everyone should have equitable access to the vaccine as expeditiously as possible, but we need to prioritize folks based on public health criteria, not on where someone is from.”
Early in the pandemic, the virus ripped through meatpacking facilities in Nebraska and nearby states, infecting thousands of workers at some plants and killing hundreds as plant managers struggled to implement health and safety measures.
During a Monday news conference, Ricketts and Nebraska health officials announced the state was planning to begin administering shots for those 75 and older, working with local health departments as well as pharmacies and medical clinics. Essential workers, including those in meatpacking plants, would not receive vaccines until later, they said.
Pressed by reporters, Ricketts repeatedly suggested no undocumented workers are employed at Nebraska meatpacking plants.
According to estimates from the Migration Policy Institute, however, undocumented workers make up about 11 percent of the workforce in meatpacking plants in Nebraska, and about 10 percent in facilities nationwide.
Castañeda, whose activist group has rallied for better protections at the Smithfield pork plant in Crete, Neb., said she has personally been in contact with over a dozen undocumented workers at the facility.
One widely shared Twitter post about Ricketts’s plan — which was retweeted by people including Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.), who called the governor’s approach “racist” — erroneously suggested he would seek to deny the vaccine to all undocumented meat packing workers.
Gage on Monday clarified that U.S. citizenship was not a requirement to receive the vaccine, noting “the federal government is expected to eventually make enough vaccine available for everyone in the country.” (He did not immediately respond to a request for comment from The Post late on Tuesday.)
And nowhere in Nebraska’s 36-page vaccination plan do officials make a note of citizenship or legal status.
For Castañeda, however, the damage may have already been done.
She said she has already been in touch with undocumented workers fearful of getting tested because they think it requires showing documents or proving their legal status. If immigration matters seep into vaccine distribution, she argued, they may be equally apprehensive about getting their first or second shot.