Originally Published in Politico
Tucker Doherty - December 3, 2020
Advocates think linking health-worker shortages with immigration policy will resonate with the incoming administration.
Thousands of foreign doctors and nurses could surge into areas overwhelmed by the coronavirus early in the Biden administration if health industry interests and advocacy groups win changes to immigration policy and reverse President Donald Trump’s crackdown on certain visas.
An estimated 10,000 physicians are in the country on H-1B visas that currently restrict where they can work — and they could face deportation if they fall ill and are unable to do their jobs. An additional 15,000 foreign nurses who’ve applied to immigrate are stuck in limbo because of consulate closures and backlogs. The Trump administration has tightened visa requirements on these and other skilled foreign workers, adding to the difficulties.
Hospital operators, medical associations and immigration groups want the incoming administration to issue executive orders and other directives after Inauguration Day to ease visa restrictions, and also are lobbying Congress on stalled legislation that would grant more foreign doctors and nurses permanent residency status — possibly by reallocating 40,000 green card slots that have gone unused in recent years.
“We’ve got open beds, we’ve got ventilators, we’ve got all the physical aspects. Our issue has been more along the lines of having staff,” said Tim Moore, CEO of the Mississippi Hospital Association. Powerful industry groups including the American Medical Association, the American Hospital Association and the American Immigration Lawyers Association have joined in the calls for change.
The Trump administration largely rebuffed the groups’ repeated requests on health workers, though the federal health department made some accommodations, like giving doctors on visas expanded use of telemedicine. There is still a remote chance further changes could be wrapped into a pandemic relief package before the end of the year.
On Tuesday, a federal judge struck down the Trump administration’s latest effort to limit high-skilled immigration. But advocates say plenty of barriers remain.
Concerns about having enough doctors and nurses to handle surging Covid caseloads have intensified over the past month, with some major hospitals again shutting down all elective procedures to free up staff. Unlike in the spring, the prevalence of the virus means there are fewer U.S. health care workers traveling to hot spots.
Much of the recent lobbying around surging foreign health workers has revolved around the Healthcare Workforce Resiliency Act, S. 3599 (116), a bill that would “recapture” thousands of unused green cards Congress authorized in previous years and reallocate them, with 25,000 reserved for nurses and 15,000 for physicians.
But despite broad support from both sides of the aisle — including lead sponsor Sen. David Perdue (R-Ga.), whose runoff election in December could determine control of the Senate — the bill has been stalled since May.
Advocates of expanded immigration and health interests expect the measure will have stronger support from the Biden White House.
“I think it has a chance of passing even if Republicans keep control of the Senate, without Trump pushing on this issue,” said Greg Siskind, a prominent immigration lawyer who specializes in health care employment. “I don’t think it’s a natural thing for Republicans to be anti-immigration. They’ve always been willing to reach bipartisan solutions, it’s only been the last four years that’s changed.”
But skeptics give it long odds in a narrowly divided Congress that's been reluctant to rewrite immigration laws. “It’s hard to get anything passed in Congress,” said Chris Musillo, an employment immigration lawyer who specializes in cases involving nurses. “Is the president a part of that? Perhaps, but I wouldn’t lay all the blame at his feet.”
Many of the bill’s green cards would go to physicians currently on H-1B visas already practicing in the U.S., giving them permanent resident status. Under the terms of their current visas, these physicians effectively cannot volunteer at other facilities due to work-site restrictions and face the possibility ofdeportation if they get sick and are unable to continue performing their job duties.
“We literally hold our breath whenever there is slight news that there might be another Covid relief bill,” said a physician working in Wisconsin on an H1-B visa, who responded to a POLITICO call out and requested anonymity to speak candidly. “But everybody would agree that it’s more likely to happen with a Biden administration.”
“Even though I want to help out, because of the visa hurdles and restrictions I’m not able to,” said another physician in Kansas with an H-1B visa, who likewise requested anonymity. “It’s frustrating because we’re willing to help wherever there is a shortage but our hands are tied.”
Other green cards would go to foreign workers overseas — mostly nurses, the most in-demand position at hospitals facing shortages — who are hoping to emigrate to the United States.
Even if the bill does not pass, advocates say the Biden administration could take action to help thousands of foreign-trained nurses who are stuck overseas.